
By Will Sturgeon
Published: Monday 19 April 2004
Email story to a Friend | Report Abuse
Name
Jim Walters
Location
Glos, uk
Occupation
Tech support
Comment
Whilst the idea or biometrics sounds good it is simply un-workable in the real world, in my opinion.
Firstly: there the cost, every point of entry in the the uk, every post office window, evry bank indow, evry police station, etc. will need a scanner, and there not cheep who's going to pay for that?
Secondly: what if you finger print is damaged or you loose and eye, how can you prove you are who you say you are?
Thirdly: what happens if the scanner give a false reading will a perfectly inocent person be arrested for teroisum because of a faulty scanner (who hasent have computer kit brake down?)
Fourthly: Lets face it criminals are going to hack it in a mater of days any way.
These are just a few of the problems.
This is just a nother scheme of "lets use a computer to fix it" touted by people who have no real idea of how the tech actually works. This seams to be a theam in all govenment tech projects, why don't thay just ask people like us.
BTW theres a system which would give the almost same level of protection but far more reliably and much much cheeper, its called a PIN and cash cards have been using it for years.
Unfortunately, with the "Am I who I say I am" rout...
Simon Walker
As David Taylor effectively, and rightly, points o...
Murdoch Mactaggart
I am against it, on the grounds of its future use,...
L Baker
Whilst the idea or biometrics sounds good it is si...
Jim Walters
Who cares? This card is not an "entitlment card" a...
Anonymous
Has anybody explained yet how ID cards will make u...
Graham Bland
60% for ID cards is a democratic mandate for the g...
Richard Sarson
50 years on, the muslims are a majority, they star...
nj
ID cards won't stop terrorism, nor will biometrics...
No ID Cards - No Biometrics
"60 per cent of readers...in favour of some form o...
Karl Buckland
To the gentleman that does not want his "personal ...
Anonymous
As a person that had an involvement in the five ye...
Larry Longdon
Agenda Setters 2009
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page
The Round-Up The Weekly Round-Up: 03.12.09 'Ere guv, you'll never guess who I had in the back of my cab the other day…'
Stuart Roberts Shared services - how to get it right in your business Recession boosts uptake