
Watch out gov't...
By Tom Espiner
Published: 12 November 2007 09:40 GMT
The government has been warned increased data sharing between departments and services could result in a decline in citizens' confidence in public bodies.
The current push by the government towards increased data sharing could backfire, with negative effects for public confidence, according to Merlin, Earl of Erroll, a member of the House of Lords Science and Technology Committee. He said schemes such as the National Identity Register - on which the government plans to hold the personal data of every UK citizen - could lead to an over-intrusive state when combined with data sharing between government departments and services.
Lord Erroll said: "With increased sharing of data, there is a greater risk of failure of public services due to the greater complexity of systems, but also people may become frightened of being caught."
He added: "If you don't tell the DVLA of a change of address, after a month you're liable to a fine of £1,000 and it will be the same under the National Identity Register. I see a problem of linking up government departments and services, like law enforcement, that are seen as enforcers and those seen as helpers, like [social services]."
silicon.com Public Sector
Get the latest public sector news straight to your inbox. Sign up for the PS newsletter today!
If someone had, for example, notified their doctor of a change of address but forgotten to notify the DVLA and this resulted in a penalty, it could undermine public confidence in both bodies, according to Lord Erroll.
He also said he was concerned about the possible data-mining implications of the scheme and added "the amount of fraud they will detect is probably less than they think".
However, Sir David Varney, the Prime Minister's adviser on public-service transformation, said the nature of the data to be shared between government departments was still under discussion.
Varney said: "There has to be a lot of careful thought about what data needs to be shared. If names, addresses and national insurance numbers were shared, people would benefit from a more personalised service."
Varney added making policy out of operational activities makes policy more credible to "customers", as it is co-produced.
Naomi Eisenstadt, director of the Cabinet Office's Social Exclusion Task Force, said a large amount of informal data sharing already exists. She said: "There can be an incredible level of intrusion. There is massive information sharing on an informal basis, as professionals chat to each other."
Tom Espiner writes for ZDNet.co.uk
I think Lord Errol is missing several points.
Fea...
Jerry
This all sounds great but the bottom line is that ...
Richard Davies
what public confidence ?
apart from voting day ...
Karen Challinor
Data Sharing??
We don't yet have joined up govern...
Roger Huffadine
What woul dconcern me most is if the government st...
Anonymous
Work with other internal departments to address issues impacting the accurate reporting of actual and expected achievement. Commercial Analyst ...
Skills & Experience: With your extensive experience selling a solution or service into senior finance related decision makers, you will have the ...
Therefore you'll be depended upon to establish strong relationships with the customer, key stakeholders, subcontractors and your opposite numbers ...
Agenda Setters 2009
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.
Stories from the web...
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page
Bob Tarzey Why you must rein in your power users When they do damage, it can be catastrophic to your business
Jon Collins Is losing a mobile device really such a big deal? How to minimise the damage to your business