
…but not necessarily less secure
By Tom Espiner
Published: 20 December 2007 11:13 GMT
Apple Mac operating systems had more critical vulnerabilities reported in 2007 than Microsoft's operating systems, according to research.
George Ou, a writer for silicon.com sister site ZDNet.com, analysed in-depth statistics from security research company Secunia as a basis for his research. He found Apple's latest operating system, Mac OS X, faced more critical flaws than Windows XP and Vista combined.
While Mac OS X had 234 highly critical vulnerabilities reported in 2007, Vista and XP combined had 23, Ou wrote.
Ou wrote: "This shows that Apple had more than five times the number of flaws per month than Windows XP and Vista in 2007 and most of these flaws are serious. Clearly this goes against conventional wisdom."
Macs have traditionally been viewed as suffering from fewer vulnerabilities than Windows.
Ou made the comparison as an indicator of how many vulnerabilities might exist in 2008, rather than a comparison of the relative security of the operating systems. He said that security had improved with both Windows Vista and Mac OS X Leopard (version 10.5) this year.
Some experts have said that counting vulnerabilities is not necessarily reliable as a measure of security.
Tristan Nitot, president of Mozilla Europe, said it was more important to take into account the time it takes to patch vulnerabilities.
The amount of exploit code available in the wild also has an impact on security. While there are thousands of pieces of code that seek to exploit Windows XP vulnerabilities, exploit code for Mac OS X is relatively rare.
Tom Espiner writes for ZDNet.co.uk
FUD.... show me one person's system on OS X that's...
Anonymous
They are basically playing with statistics here. F...
Tom B
Mr Anonomous from the USA, have you actually read ...
Windows User
Ou is simply being deceptive ... he did the same t...
Michael Fischer
I searched on the same Secunia site and found they...
Anonymous
Microsoft: Service Pack Blocker tool released
Windows Vista - why you shouldn't skip it
Poll: Vista gets vote of no confidence
Businesses delay Vista plans until 2009
Apple's Tiger and Leopard get patched up
Apple faces Macworld showdown with angry users
Apple hunts down rumour-mongers
Apple in a fix over updated iMacs?
Mac faithful up in arms about iPhone price cut
Experience and knowledge of Windows XP/Vista, Windows Server 2003. Questionmark is a growing, privately owned, international company with just under ...
Skills Knowledge of Microsoft Operating Systems (2000/XP/Vista) Knowledge of all Microsoft Office applications (Office 2000 to Office 2007) ...
Rate 10-12 per hour Required skills: Knowledge of use os MAC OS X Tiger Workstation Ability to support a MAC Environment Some understanding of ...
CIO Agenda 2008
The exclusive silicon.com CIO Agenda 2008 survey looks at the CIO's tech shopping list for the year, examines whether IT budgets are rising or falling and reveals what the pain points are for tech chiefs this year. Find out more in our latest special report.
Staffing Service Coordinates Sales Activities, Utilizes Business Intelligence With...
Teachers Association Turns to Centralized Data Repository to Improve Member Service
Financial-Software Leader Credits Productivity Boost, Reduced IT Costs to 2007 Software
United States Coast Guard Explores Potential to Enhance Training With Digital Note-Taking...
Stories from the web...
Copyright ©1995-2008 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved. Top of page
silicon.com Dear silicon.com... XP lives, the femtocell 'truth', BlackBerry bashing… Reader Comments of the Week
Martin Brampton The Brampton Factor: Open source 'brotherhood' closed to co-operation Where's the real sharing?