
Best of Reader Comments: Has Apple's time come? Or will it always be niche?
Published: 18 July 2007 15:18 GMT
silicon.com's continuing coverage of the Mac vs PC debate has sparked a furious debate among readers keen to defend their platform of choice.
In a recent interview, the CIO of property asset management company Capital & Regional kicked off the debate, telling silicon.com Macs are "smarter money and cheaper" than Microsoft's newest OS - a view that seems to be shared by some silicon.com readers who contacted us.
Reader Tom B, a scientist from Durham, predicted a widespread Windows backlash as Apple's star rises. "In a few more years, people will actually start dumping Windows in earnest, as Apple's server-side products look increasingly compelling and get infused with 64-bit goodness," he said.
The case for Macs has been building for some time, according to Reginald W who cited Apple's switch to Intel chips, OS X's ability to run "Windows and Linux and Solaris and BSD and whatever else" and the increasing number of apps written for Macs as reasons why it is becoming "a better alternative" to Windows.
His view is shared by an IS manager called Henry from Chicago, who said: "The future could swing Apple's way now that many Linux apps are being ported to OS X. All we have to do is get people to start using OpenOffice and MySQL."
When it comes to upgrading to Vista, half of silicon.com's CIO Jury recently predicted the associated costs are likely to lead to an increase in Macs on the desktop in the corporate computing environment.
In response one reader pointed to considerations beyond hard cash that give Macs an edge - such as "productivity gains" - adding: "They're very stable. Not to mention easy and a pleasure to use."
But it's not all predictions of future doom for Microsoft – some readers spoke up for the software giant and its products.
IT manager Richard Davies, a reader from North Yorkshire, emphasised the quality, reliability, support and interoperability offered by Windows platforms, adding: "The cost of moving your hardware and software to Macs or open source from PC/Windows and then providing retraining to the necessary staff in my opinion will have a higher cost than upgrading to Vista!”
He added: "My advice is stay with XP for now and simply upgrade when Vista is more business ready!"
And another reader said: "Windows will still be the most popular OS for some years to come, whatever you might say, it simply WILL be..."
They added: "Macs? Sorry but niche market, always has been and unless the OS can be distributed on the Dells and HPs of this world, with a decent set of drivers (not just for the limited Apple choices) that is how it will always be."
The Mac gaining market share is good, but please n...
Ian Hamilton
The simple fact of the matter is that the vast maj...
Paul Fullman
I sort of agree. I think that Vista has done Micro...
Chris Parsons
Macs and OSX are just not built for corporate busi...
Rob
Windows Vista is definitely one to avoid, but what...
David King
They are looking for someone with a mix of technical skills to include, Windows 2000 / 03, XP / Vista OS, Windows Server 2000 / 2003, Exchange Server ...
Keywords:Senior software engineer senior kernel engineer device driver engineer windows developer software development C/C++ Intel x86 Assembler ...
Support Analyst/ IT Trainer - German & French Speaking - (Office 2007, Legal Apps)Support Analyst / IT Trainer required by Global law firm to deliver ...
Agenda Setters 2009
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.
Stories from the web...
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page
Bob Tarzey Why you must rein in your power users When they do damage, it can be catastrophic to your business
Jon Collins Is losing a mobile device really such a big deal? How to minimise the damage to your business